Jonathan Mills

Jonathan is portrayed by Becca De La Rosa in season four and C.S.W in season seven. This page contains discussion of death, bullying, abuse, homophobia, and suicide.

Season Four
Jonathan is a member of Aurora Silver's cult and has been since he was a teenager. He records The King's voice and then loses it, which makes Aurora Silver incredibly angry. In retribution, she sends Brandon, Jonathan's apprentice (?), off to his death in the Martin House.

Jonathan grew up rich and spoiled. When he was sent to Green Pines, the academy for troubled boys he attended as a teenager, he dealt with severe abuse by his classmates, which was implied to be homophobic in nature. Aurora Silver saved him from being killed by his bullies, and he's been completely loyal to her ever since-- specifically her, not to the cult nor to the supernatural beliefs they follow.

According to the creators, it's far too late to save Jonathan from the cult.

Season Seven
Jonathan is mentioned in A Superfluity; Aurora Silver says he's been recording more messages from the King. Seeing as we don't know when this takes place in the timeline, it could be from before his last appearance.

We then hear from him in Episode Forty-Two: The Past is a Dream of Itself. He has decided to rebel against Aurora Silver because he feels Brandon's death was unfair and petty. He records a contingency plan in case he is killed and says that he has no religion or loyalty towards Aurora, who he feels is like a political extremist. He realized due to Brandon's death that none of the cultists matter to her, so he's decided to wait until he is either killed or finds a way to make the deaths of his peers mean something.

Our last time hearing from Jonathan is his final monlogue. He's speaking to Mabel, saying he had read her file (from when she was a subject) when he was still in school. He says that even if he could have, he would not have saved her, because he was more concerned with following orders. Nonetheless, he's has read the files of many subjects in an attempt to humanize them.

He says that Aurora Silver thought Mabel was special, and that he knows he isn't-- he's a foot soldier and isn't ashamed of it. He says he would have died if he has been special like Mabel was, and knows that as a soldier, he has been put to "ill use." We hear him cutting his own skin, repeating that what he's saying isn't a confession. He apologizes to Mabel and begins to break down about what happened to both her and to Brandon; he says "This isn't a confession. This is an obituary.  Get out." before noises of burning and a stag roaring overwhelm the soundscape. This implies his suicide.